These solutions to typical allowance problems will help you create an allowance system the whole family can live with.
Problem: Money is very tight. I can’t afford to pay an allowance.
Solution: If the family budget is so lean that paying an allowance seems a huge hurdle or a financial crisis keeps you from being able to pay the agreed-upon amount, consider these ideas:
- Base the allowance on what you already spend on your child. Then tell him or her exactly what the allowance is expected to cover, for example, lunch money, toy purchases, or movie tickets. That way you don’t have to look for extra money in the budget because you are simply transferring the financial responsibility to your child.
- It is reasonable to cut allowances when the family is undergoing financial hardships. Adjusting an allowa helps teach your child how to save when times are tight.
- If you have to temporarily suspend allowances because of unexpected bills, medical problems, unemployment, or any other reason, explain why this step is necessary. Also, keep track of missed allowances and try to repay them after the emergency has passed.
Problem: The child’s other parent and I can’t agree on our kid’s allowance.
Solution: Parents often have very different ideas on the amount of allowances, what they should be based on, and how frequently they should be given. Like any other parenting issue, this one can require discussion and compromise. If you can’t reach a compromise, consider letting kids have separate arrangements with each parent. Keep each other informed, but let the child know that any financial negotiations must be made with the parent paying the allowance. This is especially important for parents who are separated and have joint custody arrangements.
Problem: I keep forgetting to pay my kid’s allowance.
Solution: Take paying your child’s allowance as seriously as other financial obligations. Try one of these ideas:
- Link the allowance to your payday and get the money for your child’s allowance when you cash your check.
- For older children, set up a bank account with a debit card. If your paycheck is deposited automatically, have some of it diverted into your child’s account. This will help encourage savings and let you teach your child finance skills like balancing a bank account.
- If you keep a calendar, mark allowance dates on it to remind you when to pay.
- Set up a reminder on your cell phone or in calendar software.
- Pay a small penalty (a quarter or fifty cents) for each day the allowance is late. This will demonstrate to your child what happens when people are late paying their bills.
Problem: My kid keeps losing allowance money.
Solution: As tempting as it may be, don’t make up the money. Instead, do the following:
- Help your child search for the money.
- Help your child figure out why the money was lost and come up with possible solutions for next time. For example, if your child’s pocket has a hole in it, he or she could buy a wallet with the next allowance.
- Provide your kid with something to keep the money in such as a bank, an envelope, or a jar.
Problem: My child makes poor financial decisions, so I have to decide how to spend the allowance.
Solution: Many parents have trouble relinquishing control over how allowance money is spent—especially when a child spends wastefully. Unless the purchases are unsafe or violate your family’s values, don’t interfere. Let your kid make mistakes and learn from them. After all, making mistakes now with small amounts of money is far less costly than similar mistakes would be when your child grows up.
Don’t rescue your child when he or she has misspent an allowance and doesn’t have money for something important. For example, if you expect your child to pay for lunch from an allowance and the money is gone, have him or her make a lunch to take to school.
Problem: The allowance doesn't cover special expenses.
Solution: Consider teaching your child to manage larger amounts of money by giving a special allowance for specific expenses. For instance, you could set up a gift allowance for birthday and holiday gifts.
Clothing allowances are a good way to teach older kids how to manage substantial amounts of money. Give your child the money you would spend on clothes for back to school or the school year and explain that the money is only to be used to buy clothing. Make sure he or she understands that you won’t be adding any more money to the budget later. If your child asks for advice, give it, but let him or her make the spending decisions and live with the consequences.
Problem: When my kid doesn’t need money, he or she doesn’t do chores.
Solution: Give your child a set number of unpaid vacation days a year. Explain that there is no penalty for not doing chores (other than not getting paid) for this number of days, but after that, there are consequences such as decreasing the amount of the allowance until your child demonstrates reliability. For example, if your teen has used up the vacation days and decides not to launder the family towels, you could dock the clothing allowance.
Another tactic is refusing to do a chore that your child expects from you such as driving to sports practice or packing a lunch. Point out that since your child isn’t keeping his or her part of the bargain, you’ve decided not to keep yours.
Problem: My kid spends the allowance immediately.
Solution: This problem will likely solve itself if you don’t intervene. This means not giving advances on future allowances or paying for things the allowance is meant to cover. Let the child experience the consequences of being broke. Your child may be more careful the following week, or it may take several weeks for the lesson to sink in.
If the allowance system is set up for the child to add to savings and give to charity, you’ll need to address the consequences of “borrowing” from the other allowance accounts. One tactic is to let the child can draw money out for specific expenditures and pay back extra money. Since your child is managing the money, let him or her decide on and enforce the penalty.
Problem: My child complains that the allowance is too small.
Solution: This is a great opportunity for your child to learn financial negotiation skills. Have your child to make a formal proposal for an allowance increase that includes the following information:
- Why the increase is needed
- A list of expenses
- How the increase will be spent
- What additional chores the child is willing to do to get the increase
After you read the proposal, explain why the allowance is at the current level. Let your child respond. Based on your child’s proposal and the negotiations, decide whether or not to increase the allowance.
Problem: My child lends money to siblings or friends who don’t pay it back.
Solution: This is a lesson that can be very difficult for a child and the parent who wants to cultivate generosity and kindness. These steps can help.
- Find out exactly what happened.
- Listen carefully to your child’s explanations and feelings about the incident.
- Discuss the damage lending can do to a friendship as well as praising your child’s generosity.
- Help your child find a solution.
- Discuss what your child will do differently next time.
If the loan was made to a sibling, include that sibling in the discussion. If possible, try to lead your kids to an equitable solution such as the borrower’s next allowance getting paid directly to the lender—with interest.